In current weeks, blaming every little thing on Proposition 47 has made a comeback. Why?
It’s easy: it’s an election yr.
California Republican politicians and pundits are caught within the Eighties in terms of crime, legal justice and policing. They suppose it makes good politics to magnify the extent of crime and scapegoating insurance policies like Proposition 47. And in some jurisdictions, it’s.
Therefore, Republican Assemblymembers Kevin Kiley of Rocklin, James Gallagher of Yuba Metropolis, and James Patterson of Fresno have launched payments in Sacramento to both completely repeal or partially repeal Prop. 47.
Prop. 47, for context, lowered a handful of crimes from felonies to misdemeanors. Notably, it had the help of Newt Gingrich and Rand Paul on the time. It was accepted in 2014 with almost 60% of the vote.
Kiley, unsurprisingly, is as soon as once more operating for one more workplace. That’s all he appears to do, having misplaced races for state Senate and governor in the previous few years. He introduced his run for Congress quickly after introducing his invoice to repeal Prop. 47, which yielded loads of information tales even though everybody is aware of it has zero probability of getting anyplace. It’s not presupposed to. It’s about grabbing headlines and reinforcing worn out narratives. That’s all.
And, let’s face it, for higher or worse (and I’d say it’s for the more serious), being within the superminority, Meeting Republicans usually appear at peace with being irrelevant and pandering to their shrinking base.
Kiley’s motive for introducing a pointless invoice is similar motive Democratic Assemblyman Rudy Salas of Bakersfield launched his personal Prop. 47 repeal invoice. Salas, who’s plainly within the pocket of the police and jail guard unions, can also be operating for Congress and needed to show to Republican voters that he’s not like these different Democrats, or no matter.
Now, having mentioned of this, politicians will do what they do. Being a fraud is within the job description. However media shops have contributed to this farce.
The Fresno Bee editorial board determined to leap on this previous week with an completely inane take.
The Fresno Bee referred to as for putting Prop. 47 again on the poll, after uncritically quoting Patterson as saying, “The explanation crime statistics are down is as a result of they modified the type of crimes reported within the statistics.”
I’ll assist out the Fresno Bee editorial board and Patterson. The California Division of Justice publishes crime experiences, with explanations of what goes into the experiences and even breakdowns of the crimes. You’ll be able to go to oag.ca.gov/crime.
On web page three of the 2020 Crime in California report, they is perhaps stunned to search out this be aware, “It’s not attainable to tell apart felony from misdemeanor larceny-theft. Subsequently, it was determined to incorporate complete larceny-theft crime within the property crime class no matter worth.” They could even be stunned to see breakdowns of larceny-theft into classes, together with as little as $50 or much less.
And, for the file, larceny-theft charges per 100,000 folks have declined from 1,538 since Prop. 47’s passage in 2014 to 1,326 in 2020.
Notably, the Fresno Bee editorial board didn’t hassle to acknowledge Proposition 20’s existence or defeat. That was the 2020 measure to curtail legal justice reforms, together with Prop. 47.
They have to’ve forgotten they opposed Proposition 20, calling it “a retrograde and racist jail spending rip-off.”
The Fresno Bee editorial board, I assume, has determined to now help “a retrograde and racist jail spending rip-off.” Odd.
Prop. 47 isn’t the issue. Cynical politicians and half-baked media takes are the issue, for they mislead the general public and waste time on nonsense after they could possibly be engaged on precise options to precise issues.
It ought to be remembered that Prop. 47 has freed up greater than $500 million since 2014, which is required beneath the measure to be reinvested in crime prevention, drug therapy applications and different a lot wanted efforts. However don’t count on to listen to an acknowledgment of that from those that whine about Prop. 47.
Sal Rodriguez could be reached at email@example.com